Finding bargain craft tools

Have you ever compared the price of a women’s disposable razor to the price of the same thing sold for men? Or been part of planning a wedding? If so you are aware that prices can vary widely based on who is buying the product. The rule of thumb is that the larger the market, the smaller the price.

When we apply that principle to craft tools we can find some bargains.

In the kitchen section

  • Baking mats – Thick silicone mats, sometimes called silicone pastry mats, are similar to “water media mats”. My favorite is this one https://amzn.to/3nDdM0r
  • Muffin tins – Handy for sorting small items, especially six-cup or mini-muffin tins. I like the individual silicone cups like these https://amzn.to/3nDdM0r
  • Plate rack – Handy for holding vertical items like scoreboard, stamping tool, palettes, and similar small items that don’t stack neatly. I’m using this one https://amzn.to/3nDdM0r
  • Dough scraper – Fabulous for applying paste across a stencil, and with an inexpensive multipack you can actually leave one in the kitchen for dough! https://amzn.to/3nDdM0r
  • Lazy Susan (turntable) – So useful for storing items in a hard-to-reach corner, whether that’s inside a cabinet (as intended) or on the corner of your craft desk https://amzn.to/3nDdM0r

In the office section

  • White board erasers – Use this instead of a specialty stamp pressure tool (to press on the cover of a stamping tool). I got a package of cute ones that are magnetic to boot https://amzn.to/42yAHcd
  • Magazine holders and paper sorters – These are, after all, the same size as 8 1/2 x 11 craft paper so why not? Cardboard magazine holders are particularly inexpensive. For 12 x 12 paper, you can construct your own magazine holder with almost any corrugated box and some hot glue.
  • Glue – When it comes to craft adhesive, the majority of the price is in the dispenser. If you are buying glue tubes or fine-tip bottles, you can save a ton by decanting Elmer’s Extra Strong or Aleene’s Tacky Glue into smaller bottles like these https://amzn.to/42yAHcd

In the makeup section

  • Nail polish organizers – Perfect for 1-ounce bottles such as reinkers or drops, or the 1-ounce needle-nose bottles I use for glue.
  • Make up brushes and sponges – Instead of craft blending brushes or pouncers, try the mass-marketed makeup versions. The ergonomic blending brushes (palm hold instead of handle) are usually called foundation brushes.

#GetMessyMay 2 showing up

My entrance to papercrafting was traditional scrapbooking back in the early ’90s, so I’m taking a scrapbook approach to this month’s journal. For prompt #2, showing up, I chose a vintage pic of my three dogs waiting at the front door for a visitor to show up.

The left side is a magazine cover, with gesso and stenciling, and the right is the paper from the bottom of my splat box.

Might as well use some of that overspray! Tomorrow’s prompt is “happy.”

#GetMessyMay starting

I’m going to participate in the journal challenge #getmessymay. The prompts are

And for prompt #1 starting I choose to put together a junk journal from a Pink Paislee wood album that was a cross-promotion with Tattered Angels, something that’s been in my crafty stash so long it pre-dates the acquisition of Pink Paislee by American Crafts in 2013. It’s part of my challenge to myself to use what I have and not shop. For pages, I’m using various colors of copy paper, some magazine pages, and some paper bags. The journal-in-progress:

Short video here: https://youtu.be/3LciYXShq8Y

Your craft space can look better in an hour

We don’t all have the time or money to install a custom craft space, but you can create a co-ordinated look with your paper craft skills. A consistent label can unify many different types of containers.

You can see in this photo I have fifteen different types of containers. I used whatever I had around the house – mostly shoe boxes in cardboard or plastic, but a couple of smaller containers from the dollar store, and some kitchen organizers.

You can (obviously) create your own labels, but I’m attaching mine in case you’d rather print those than make your own.

You can fussy-cut to keep the shape, or cut in a straight rectangle in the interest of speed. I’ve included a couple of blanks in case your categories don’t match my categories.

Stamping options

Mounted stamps

Traditional red rubber stamps often come mounted (permanently adhered) to a wooden block.

Un-mounted stamps

To save cost and storage space, many new stamps come unmounted.  The red rubber or clear photopolymer stamp must be temporarily mounted in order to stamp.

Acrylic block

The lowest cost option is an acrylic block.  The block will easily pick up the clear photopolymer stamp or the gray cushion on a red rubber stamp.

Stamp Platforms

A stamp platform is an alternative to an acrylic or wooden block that allows repeat stamping in the exact same place.  Stamp platforms can be used with red rubber or clear photopolymer stamps.

Stampin Up Stamparatus $50

7” x 7” base, allows material larger than that to hang out on two sides, offers two reversible lids for layer stamping up to four images (discontinued in 2023, may find used)

Misti by My Sweet Petunia $70

6.5” x 8.5”, enclosed so material cannot hang out and must fit within size of device

Memory Misti is 12 x 12, $109

Sizzix Stencil and Stamp Tool $60

8.25” x 11.75”, open on three sides, offers a stencil holder (that gets bad reviews)

Tonic Tim Holtz Stamp Platform Discontinued in USA

Came in 8’ x 8” and 12” x 12”, open on two sides, for about $35.  Worth seeking out used or overseas.

Not quite the same:

Altenew stamp wheel – entire top layer comes off, no hinge, has the ability to turn to create a stamped wreath, integral sticky mat $100

Crafter’s Companion – it’s more like an acrylic block with springy legs, not a stamping platform

Fiskar’s Easy Stamp Press – another acrylic block on legs

Also check out localkingrubberstamp.com for Lisa’s tutorial (#45 in the video library) for making your own from a CD case, or follow the link to YouTube:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KHl54k4OxQ

Details on Adhesive

Details from my analysis of adhesive. All prices in US dollars, and your price may vary based on bulk buying, coupons, shipping, taxes, and so forth. You are paying for the dispenser and the less dispenser you pay for the less expensive the product.

LIQUID GLUE

Lawn Fawndamentals glue tube 11.00 per ounce 0.55 per foot

Gina K Connect 11.00 per ounce 0.55 per foot

Aleene’s Tacky Glue pen 9.40 per ounce 0.47 per foot

Nuvo Smooth Precision glue pen 8.01 per ounce 0.40 per foot

Elmer’s Precision glue pen 4.67 per ounce 0.23 per foot

Nuvo Deluxe Adhesive 4.99 per ounce 0.25 per foot

Ranger Glossy Accents 3.28 per ounce 0.16 per foot

Reptile Premium craft adhesive 2.70 per ounce 0.27 per foot

Reptile in needle nose 1 oz 0.14 per foot

Bearly Art Precision Craft Glue 1.64 per ounce 0.08 per foot

Elmer’s Glue All Extra Strong 0.31 per ounce 0.03 per foot

Elmer’s in needle nose 1 oz 0.02 per foot

Aleene’s Original Tacky Glue 0.31 per ounce 0.03 per foot

Aleene’s in needle nose 1 oz 0.02 per foot

Big bottle, regular tip repackaged into a one-ounce needle-nose bottle is the least costly.

TAPE RUNNERS

Scotch Extra Strength tape runner 0.33  per foot

Tombow Xtreme tape runner 0.28 per foot

Scotch Create tape runner 0.19 per foot

Elmer’s tape runner 0.19 per foot

Duck Easy Stick tape runner 0.19 per foot

3L E-Z strips tape runner 0.15 per foot

AdTech tape runner 0.12 per foot

American Crafts Sticky Thumb  0.11 per foot

Tombow Mono tape runner 0.11 per foot

Sookwang tear tape 0.08 per foot

ATG refill 0.08 per foot

Recollections tape runner 0.07 per foot

Scor-tape tear tape 0.06 per foot

Tear tape with no dispenser is the least costly.

 

Cost-efficient adhesive

I continued my review of all my adhesives and learned a few things:

  • Liquid glue is pretty much the same; I’m paying for the dispenser.
    • Glue pens are the most costly per ounce, and big bottles with big nozzles are the cheapest. No great surprise there, but the least expensive glue is an astonishing 1/36 the price based on a per-ounce calculation. Is Gina K Connect 36 times better than Aleene’s? No, no it is not. I put the cheap glue in a one-ounce needle nose bottle for the most bang for my adhesive buck.
    • After testing all 14 (!) kinds, I understand why Bearly Arts and Art Glitter are so popular since they run about $1.60 an ounce, but Elmer’s Glue All Extra Strong or Aleene’s Original Tacky Glue in a one-ounce needle nose bottle is 1/8 the price and just as good.
  • Tape runner is not inherently more expensive than glue. I calculated the price per foot for liquid glue and tape runners, thinking liquid glue would run away with this competition… but it didn’t.
    • Tape runners also increase in price based on the dispenser. Disposables cost the most, refillables cost less, and no-dispenser tear tape costs the least.
    • The price per foot for tear tape, ATG refills, and no-name tape runners is around $0.06 – $0.08 while Elmer’s/Aleene’s/Bearly Arts/Art Glitter runs $0.02 – $0.08.
  • I need to stop buying adhesive because I have a lifetime supply.

Ink pads

There are five types of ink pads:

  • Dye ink
  • Pigment ink
  • Hybrid (dye/pigment) ink
  • Alcohol ink
  • Embossing ink

Prices generally start around $7 per ink pad for a “full size” pad which is generally 2” x 3”.  Mini ink pads cost about half and are generally 1” x 1”, but contain roughly 20% as much ink as a full size ink pad.  Ink pads can be made of a felt pad with linen cover or made of foam.

Dye ink pads are quick-drying.  They can be either water-reactive or non-water-reactive.  One common type of traditional, non-water-reactive dye ink pad is Stampin Up.  The most common type of water-reactive dye ink is Ranger Distress by Tim Holtz.  There are many brands of both types, including Simon Says Stamp, Hero Arts, and Altenew.  

Most stamping is done with dye ink, whether water-reactive or not.  Dye ink should be used for stamping an image to be colored with alcohol ink markers (e.g. Copic).  

Pigment ink pads are slow-drying.  Brands include Versafine (by Tsukineko) and Ranger Archival.

Hybrid ink pads have elements of both dye and pigment.  They can be water-reactive (like Ranger Distress Oxide by Tim Holtz) or non-water-reactive.  There are many brands, although most are non-water-reactive.

Alcohol ink pads are used for non-porous surfaces such as tile or plastic.   The most common brand is Staz-On.

Embossing ink is a clear, sticky ink used for tone-on-tone stamping or embossing.  The most common brand is Versamark.

Pigment, hybrid, alcohol, or embossing ink should be used for stamping an image to be colored with a water medium (e.g. watercolor paint.)  Any sticky, slow-drying ink can be used for embossing, including pigment, hybrid, and embossing ink.

Manual die cut machines – basics and optional extras

Manual die cut machines are human-powered and offer a platform with rollers.  You crank a “sandwich” of cutting plate, die, and paper (or other material to be cut) through the rollers with a handle.

Basic pieces

  • machine
  • two cutting plates
  • multipurpose platform or adapter
  • die (shape cutter)

The standard cutting plates are a hard polycarbonate plastic.  They are consumable, so they will need to be replaced periodically.  Turn the plates over top to bottom, left to right, with every cut to reduce warping.  

The multipurpose platform or adapter raises the cutting plates so you can use thin dies instead of steel rule dies.  

You can successfully die cut with the basic pieces.  

Optional extras

  • self-healing cutting plate
  • extended cutting plates
  • chrome precision base plate
  • metal shim
  • magnetic plate
  • silicone pad / impression pad pair
  • die brush 

The standard cutting plates can be swapped for a self-healing plate on the cutting surface.  These are available from scrapbook.com or iCrafter or you can cut your own from any self-healing mat.  

Extended cutting plates are needed IF you have an extra-long die.

The chrome precision plate and metal shim may be useful for cutting detailed thin dies.  You can also add paper or cardstock shims to your sandwich.

A magnetic plate will gently hold thin steel dies in place.  You can also use low-tack tape.

The floppy silicone pad and softer (than polycarbonate) impression pad are used together to emboss (rather than cut) from a thin steel die.

A die brush or die pick can be used to eject small pieces of paper from cutting dies.

Dies and Embossing Folders

  • steel rule dies
  • thin steel dies
  • embossing folders

Steel rule dies are thick and heavy, 4 ounces or more, and cat cut chipboard, cardboard, or multiple layers of cardstock.  New dies are quite expensive, generally $40 and up, and the only company still making these is Sizzix.  

Thin steel dies are very thin, comparable to a few sheets of cardstock.  Generally these should be used to cut a single layer of cardstock. These are widely available from many manufacturers and designers at a wide range of prices.  Some thin dies are words or basic shapes, while others are made to cut out a co-ordinating stamped image.

Embossing folders are two pieces of plastic, hinged, that have a positive raised image on one side and a negative debossed image on the other.  You put a piece of paper between the two and run it through the die cut machine to emboss the image onto the paper.  These are also widely available and inexpensive.